12/12/ · Imprisonment alone does not work, but combined with other methods like rehab or therapy, it can work. Locking away a prisoner and throwing away the key does not help society. Although it does accomplish one of the goals of punishment, incapacitation, imprisonment does not work. I think that imprisonment is overused, especially in the United States According to Wilbert Rideau's opinion, prisons do not work, and there are various reasons why this happens. As indicated in the last paragraph essay, one of the major problems of prisons circulates in the fact that politicians take the easy way to make the people think Some people have to be put in prison. This assignment looks at why and then whether prison works as an answer to all serious crime committed by adults. Is prison there simply to punish people or to make them better people, to deter them from committing more crime or just to make society feel safer?
Does prison work Essay - Words
in ArticlesOpinion. You can read the winning and excellent essays here. Traditionally prisons have been argued to serve at least one of three functions: to punish the prisoner, to protect the public, and to rehabilitate the offender to prevent them committing another crime. However, on closer inspection, the reasons given seem to have secondary important to the need for society to feel like something is being done, that justice is being served, that law and order is being kept, with near-total disregard for those who find themselves shut out of society with no hope of redemption.
The first function given for prison, punishment, has always seemed to have the least force. Setting aside the dubious civility of a society which seeks revenge upon its citizenry, is spending £30, a year on keeping someone in prison when most prisoners really hurting them, or us? Which leaves the protection of the public as the remaining reason, and the reason that prisons came about in the first place.
Imprisoning those who threaten others seems slightly more justifiable. But this has to be balanced with the human rights of those convicted of crimes themselves — can we justify the imprisonment of such people?
Does our society ultimately benefit from keeping people away under lock and key? Inthe psychologist Terrie Moffett published a paper in the Psychological Review that argued that there were two fundamental types of prisoner — the adolescent-limited and the lifelong-persistent. The adolescent-limited are young, primarily men, who commit crime to support themselves, for fun, as part of a gang, or other reasons, who eventually mature, settle down and give up the lifestyle that was contributing to their criminality.
The second type, lifelong-persistent, are people who commit crimes casually and often, moving through the criminal justice does prison work essay in a perpetual cycle of crime-arrest-conviction-incarceration-release-crime and rarely, if ever, breaking out of that cycle.
There are a variety of reasons both types end up in prison, including poor education, drug addiction, does prison work essay, racism young black men are twice as likely to go to prison than to university. Neither type of prisoner are prevented from committing more crime or given the chance to change their lives through serving prison sentences.
The adolescent-limited, young and not really thinking about the consequences of their actions, find themselves permanently disadvantaged for the rest of their lives; upon release from prison, they struggle to find housing, meaningful employment and integration into society. It becomes easier to continue to commit more crimes to support themselves. Likewise, the lifelong-persistent are let down by our society.
To deal with the reasons for people returning to prison over and over again, we require drug treatment programmes, mental health treatment, does prison work essay, adult education, housing programmes, and ways of giving people pride and hope in themselves. But, when regarding that list, how much of it can be achieved effectively in a prison? Their attitude is largely that prison is for punishing people that society disapproves of.
Jon Venables and Robert Thompson were both locked up for ten years — one has now been rehabilitated and is trying to build a new life, one has gone back into prison for breaking his does prison work essay. The press wants to see them both imprisoned at great cost to the taxpayer regardless of their current circumstances, and with the broad support of their readers, it seems.
With such calls, can we really say society cares about whether prison works or not? Ultimately, the way we treat prisoners as a society reflect on our humanity. People who kill, rape, steal, assault and engage in other anti-social behaviour are causing us as individuals and as a community harm and need to be dealt with. We need evidence-based solutions to tackle the problems that leads people to commit crime, does prison work essay. But is prison really effective at this? Can prison deal with poverty, drug addiction, racism, patriarchy, social breakdown, senses of insecurity, resentment, or entitlement?
The evidence would suggest that as a society we have got our definition very wrong. Accessed 19th April, Subscribe to SarahMcCulloch. com via Email! or via RSS! Tagged as: arghcrimeevidence-based policypenal reformprisonsociety. Society itself is guilty of all these crime-actions. You are missing the three most fundamental points :. Crime as a concept does not make rational sense.
Society has no right to interfere in the criminal acts of any criminal because it created the criminal and commits more crime-acts than any criminal ever possibly could. Society chooses to deliberately sponsor and promote the causes of does prison work essay. While you may have a point regarding points 1 and 3, refusing to deal with violent acts at all is quite stupid.
However, your entire website is devoted to condemning the actions of society in this regard. What is the difference does prison work essay an act of violence perpetrated on the individual by the state, and an act of violence perpetrated on the individual by an individual? There is none, does prison work essay.
Sarah has a good point but how can we end crime? We cant, but reduce the amount by treating people who are drug abusers like addict and not someone who rapes steal does prison work essay kills. residential rehab programmes cost about half of what imprisonment costs per week. Imagine what would happen to crime if we just gave all of the people who commit acquisitive crime the drugs they were after for free.
So rehab can definitely work on a large scale — but in terms of wider crime, there is a significant link between educational attainment and petty crime, as well as the availability of job opportunities. If we sorted those out as a society, most of our prisons would simply be unnecessary.
It can make terrific and instant meals for breakfast, lunch and dinner, and is perfect for traveling, excursions, does prison work essay, and parties. what do you mean by is spending £30, a year on keeping someone in prison when most prisoners really hurting them, does prison work essay, or us?
The average worker in the UK earns £22k a year. Say they lose approximately half that income in taxation. This is ridiculous. Home Back About Me Blog Contact. Change colour scheme: standard blue yellow lime pink. com With Strength and Spirit Sarah McCulloch. com Sarah McCulloch. Now CV Profile About Me Writing Shakespeare Slam Reviews Essays Projects Desktop Backgrounds Polyphasic Sleeping Polarised — A documentary on LGBTQ Mental Does prison work essay Drug Policy Luminary Uprise God Made the Rainbow Media Blog Contact Moderation Policy.
Visit the Howard League does prison work essay Penal Reform. Related Posts: Everyone Vs. Peter Reynolds Lol Peter Reynolds vs. Everyone Apparently Peter Reynolds and the Rampant Sexism Aimed at Me Free Market Capitalists and Anarchism does prison work essay a Short Play Chavs: A Review of The Demonisation of the Working Class Tagged as: arghcrimeevidence-based policypenal reformprisonsociety, does prison work essay.
You are missing the three most fundamental points : 1. Visit MY website Forbidden Truth Media for the Truth on society, crime and humanity, does prison work essay. Hi Wolf, residential rehab programmes cost about half of what imprisonment costs per week.
Cancel reply Leave a Comment. Search for:. In Memoriam Jeff Home Back About Me Blog Contact.
The surprising reason our correctional system doesn't work - Brandon W. Mathews - TEDxMileHigh
, time: 15:18Do Prisons Work Essay example - Words | Bartleby
21/10/ · Imprisonment alone does not work, but combined with other methods like rehab or therapy, it can work. Locking away a prisoner and throwing away the key does not help society. Although it does accomplish one of the goals of punishment, incapacitation, imprisonment does not work. I think that imprisonment is overused, especially in the United States 12/12/ · Imprisonment alone does not work, but combined with other methods like rehab or therapy, it can work. Locking away a prisoner and throwing away the key does not help society. Although it does accomplish one of the goals of punishment, incapacitation, imprisonment does not work. I think that imprisonment is overused, especially in the United States 30/9/ · The work of Joyce () suggests that there are five objectives that are analysed when looking to see if prisons work, these are punishment, reform, incapacitation, deterrence and denunciation. However due to the limited word count this essay will only look at three key factors of prisons including punishment, rehabilitation and security
No comments:
Post a Comment